ST. LOUIS – The following Pioneer Football League student-athletes were recognized by various organizations as among the best in the NCAA's Football Championship Subdivision during the 2024 season.
Mari Adams, Sr., RB, Davidson
- Walter Payton Award Finalist (t-27th)
Hope Adebayo, Sr., RB, St. Thomas
- Walter Payton Award Finalist (t-24th)
Finn Claypool, RJr., DL, Drake
- Third Team Stats Perform FCS All-America
- Honorable Mention Associated Press FCS All-America
- Buck Buchanan Award Finalist (t-26th)
Jackson Conners-McCarthy, Fr., TE, Marist
- Honorable Mention Associated Press FCS All-America
- Stats Perform FCS Freshman All-America Team
Eric Haney, Sr., DB, San Diego
- Honorable Mention Associated Press FCS All-America
Collin Hurst, Fr., QB, Presbyterian
- Jerry Rice Award Finalist (10th)
Sam Johnson, Sr., P, Valparaiso
- Second Team Stats Perform FCS All-America Team
Paul Kelly, Fr., PR, Dayton
- Stats Perform FCS Freshman All-America Team
Gideon Lampron, So., LB, Dayton
- First Team Associated Press FCS All-America
- Third Team Stats Perform FCS All-America
- Buck Buchanan Award Finalist (15th)
Malik McDaniel, Sr., OL, Davidson
- Honorable Mention Associated Press FCS All-America
Ja'Seem Reed, Sr., WR, San Diego
- Second Team Associated Press FCS All-America
Drew VanVleet, RFr., QB, Dayton
- Jerry Rice Award Finalist (23rd)