The PFL Recap: Nov. 14

Butler, Dayton remain tied entering final week; Koch scores five times for St. Thomas

11/15/2026 1:23:27 AM

By: Cody Bush, PFL Media Relations Director

Butler and Dayton each improved to 6-1 in Pioneer Football League play Saturday, leaving the two teams tied atop the standings entering the final weekend. Dayton holds the head-to-head tiebreaker. Butler shut out Marist 28-0, and Dayton held Davidson to three points in a 34-3 victory. St. Thomas remained a game behind the leaders at 5-2 after Joseph Koch scored five rushing touchdowns in a 55-35 win over Drake. Morehead State held off a second-half rally by Presbyterian to win 28-25, while Valparaiso beat Stetson 34-31 on Luke Scoma’s field goal as time expired. Dayton visits Presbyterian and Butler hosts Morehead State in their regular-season finales..

PFL Scoreboard

Saturday, November 14
Morehead State def. Presbyterian, 28-25
Dayton def. Davidson, 34-3
Butler def. Marist, 28-0
St. Thomas def. Drake, 55-35
Valparaiso def. Stetson, 34-31

PFL Recaps

Morehead State 28, Presbyterian 25

MOREHEAD, Ky. — David Parsons threw four touchdown passes in the first half, and Morehead State held off Presbyterian’s late comeback effort for a 28-25 Pioneer Football League victory Saturday at Phil Simms Stadium. The Eagles ended a two-game conference losing streak and improved to 2-5 in league play.

Parsons gave Morehead State a 14-0 first-quarter lead with touchdown passes of 19 yards to Anthony Ice and 26 yards to Keegan Zylstra. Max Holtzclaw answered with a 1-yard touchdown run for Presbyterian, but Parsons struck twice more in the second quarter, finding Ice for a 35-yard score and Zylstra for a 56-yard touchdown on a one-play drive. The Eagles led 28-10 at halftime.

After a scoreless third quarter, Presbyterian turned to Jayden Torres at quarterback and cut the deficit to 28-18 on his 40-yard touchdown pass to Jalen Patrick and a two-point conversion. Torres found Patrick again for a 25-yard touchdown with 2:12 remaining, drawing the Blue Hose within three points. Presbyterian recovered another Morehead State fumble to regain possession, but Tazion McQueen intercepted a third-down pass at the Eagles’ 9-yard line with 35 seconds left to preserve the victory.

Parsons finished with 273 passing yards, while Zylstra caught five passes for 168 yards and two touchdowns. Torres threw for 169 yards and two scores for Presbyterian, and Patrick had six receptions for 94 yards and two touchdowns.

Dayton 34, Davidson 3

DAYTON, Ohio — Dayton held Davidson to 25 rushing yards and 179 yards of total offense in a 34-3 Pioneer Football League victory Saturday at Welcome Stadium. The Flyers improved to 6-1 in conference play, remaining tied with Butler atop the standings with one week to play.

Davidson opened the game with an 11-play drive that produced a 35-yard field goal by Christos Tzoumakas. Dayton took the lead late in the first quarter on Bryce Schondelmyer’s 31-yard touchdown pass to Gavin Lochow. The Flyers then put together an 18-play, 73-yard drive that consumed 8:34, with Luke Hansen scoring on an 11-yard run. David Maurer’s 26-yard field goal extended Dayton’s halftime lead to 17-3.

Dayton’s defense kept Davidson off the scoreboard in the second half. Javawn Brooks intercepted Casey Bullock in the third quarter, and Schondelmyer later connected with Michael Mussari for a 24-yard touchdown. Maurer added a 32-yard field goal in the fourth quarter before Jaz Boykin’s interception gave the Flyers the ball at the Davidson 25, setting up Tyler Brown’s 16-yard touchdown run.

Schondelmyer threw for 183 yards and two touchdowns, while Mussari caught seven passes for 91 yards. For Davidson, Bullock passed for 154 yards and AJ Adams had 10 receptions for 62 yards.

Butler 28, Marist 0

POUGHKEEPSIE, N.Y. — Butler recorded seven sacks and two interceptions on its way to a 28-0 shutout of Marist Saturday at Tenney Stadium. The Bulldogs remained tied with Dayton atop the Pioneer Football League at 6-1, while Marist fell to 4-3 in conference play.

After a scoreless first quarter, Michael Dellumo capped Butler’s eight-play, 61-yard drive with a 6-yard touchdown run four seconds into the second. Marist threatened later in the half, but Andrew Lieske intercepted Sonny Mannino on fourth-and-4 at the Butler 13. The Bulldogs took a 7-0 lead into halftime after missing a field goal on the final play of the half.

Butler added to its lead in the third quarter when Dellumo scored from 3 yards out after the Bulldogs took over in Marist territory. Later, Gabe Passini converted fourth-and-7 with a 15-yard completion to Nick Munson, keeping an 11-play drive alive before finishing it with a 1-yard touchdown run. On Marist’s next possession, Tristan Johnson intercepted Mannino on third-and-11 and returned the ball 42 yards to the Marist 6. Desmin Jackson scored on the next play to make it 28-0.

Passini rushed for 64 yards and threw for 101, while Dellumo scored twice. For Marist, Mannino passed for 138 yards but was sacked six times. The Red Foxes finished with 52 rushing yards and converted just two of 15 third-down attempts.

St. Thomas 55, Drake 35

ST. PAUL, Minn. — Joseph Koch rushed for 233 yards and five touchdowns to lead St. Thomas past Drake 55-35 Saturday at O’Shaughnessy Stadium. The Tommies improved to 5-2 in Pioneer Football League play, one game behind co-leaders Butler and Dayton entering the regular-season finale.

St. Thomas scored the game’s first 34 points, including 27 in the opening quarter. Koch opened the scoring with a 10-yard run before Anthony Policare connected with Quentin Cobb-Butler for an 80-yard touchdown and Aaron Boarman for a 69-yard score. Policare added a 1-yard rushing touchdown, and Koch scored again early in the second quarter. Drake got on the scoreboard before halftime on Cody Blicharz’s 1-yard run.

Koch’s 23-yard touchdown run extended the lead to 41-7 in the third quarter. Drake responded with touchdown passes from Riley Warzynski to Hank Foley and Lincoln DeLaere, but Koch answered with a 9-yard scoring run early in the fourth. Lucci Fidone returned the ensuing kickoff 93 yards for a Drake touchdown, and Warzynski later found DeLaere again to complete a 99-yard drive. Koch capped the scoring with his fifth touchdown, a 5-yard run with 4:42 remaining.

Policare threw for 283 yards and two touchdowns for St. Thomas, which finished with 269 rushing yards. Warzynski passed for 434 yards and three touchdowns for Drake, while DeLaere caught six passes for 61 yards and two scores. Drake was held to minus-8 rushing yards.

Valparaiso 34, Stetson 31

DELAND, Fla. — Luke Scoma kicked a 28-yard field goal as time expired, lifting Valparaiso past Stetson 34-31 Saturday at Spec Martin Memorial Stadium. The Beacons improved to 4-3 in Pioneer Football League play after rallying from a seven-point fourth-quarter deficit.

Stetson struck first on Chris Stephenson’s 40-yard touchdown pass to Shawne Jones, but Rowan Keefe answered with an 11-yard scoring pass to Devin Yeats. After the Hatters went back ahead 10-7, Scoma tied the game with a field goal. Later in the second quarter, Max Samuel blocked a Stetson punt to give Valparaiso a short field, and Keefe found Kam Fouty-Koonce for a 3-yard touchdown that put the Beacons ahead 16-10 at halftime.

The lead changed hands repeatedly in the third quarter. Landon Farco returned a punt 65 yards for a Stetson touchdown, and Russell Tye answered with a 4-yard touchdown run for Valparaiso. A successful two-point conversion gave the Beacons a 24-17 lead, but Stephenson found Troy Flowers for the tying touchdown. Stephenson then connected with Anthony Benzija for a 67-yard score on the final play of the quarter, giving Stetson a 31-24 lead. Cedric Benning III tied the game with a 3-yard run early in the fourth. Valparaiso took over at its 17 with 4:24 remaining and drove 72 yards to set up Scoma’s winning kick.

Keefe threw for 303 yards and two touchdowns, and Chris Gundy caught eight passes for 122 yards for Valparaiso. Stephenson passed for 306 yards and three scores for Stetson, while Jones caught four passes for 131 yards.